Fix Your Broken Toilet Handle: Easy DIY Solutions

Plumbing

Blog
// Posted by Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc.

A broken toilet handle can be a big hassle, but you might be able to fix it yourself. This guide will show you how to replace your broken flush lever, no matter the type of handle you have. It's easy and quick to do.

Before you begin, know that you can buy a replacement kit at a hardware store. This is cheaper than calling a professional plumber. Plumbers usually charge between $40 and $200 per hour. So, fixing the toilet handle yourself can save you a lot of money.

Key Takeaways

  • Many common toilet handle issues can be fixed by homeowners without specialized plumbing knowledge.
  • Replacing a toilet handle is a straightforward DIY project that can save money compared to hiring a professional plumber.
  • Identifying the type of toilet handle (front-mounted, side-mounted, or angle-mounted) is the first step in the replacement process.
  • Having the right tools and parts on hand is essential for a successful toilet handle repair.
  • Proper installation and adjustment of the new toilet handle is crucial to ensure proper flushing function.

Identify Your Toilet Handle Type

Fixing or replacing a broken toilet handle starts with knowing its type. Toilet handles come in three main types: front-mounted, side-mounted, and angle-mounted. Knowing your handle type helps you get the right replacement part.

Front-Mounted Handles

Front-mounted toilet handles are the most common. They sit on the front of the tank, usually in the top right corner. These handles are easy to get to and simple to replace.

Side-Mounted Handles

Side-mounted toilet handles are on the side of the tank. They have a longer spindle because they go through the tank side. Make sure the new handle has the right spindle length when replacing a side-mounted one.

Angle-Mounted Handles

Angle-mounted toilet handles are set at an angle on the tank side. They're less common but found on some older or specialty toilets. These handles need a special replacement part, so check the type before buying.

It's key to measure the handle and tank hole size, no matter the handle type. With the correct replacement part and some basic tools, you can fix a broken toilet handle easily. This will get your bathroom working again.

Gather the Necessary Tools

Before you start replacing your toilet handle, make sure you have the right tools. This will make the job easier and help you do it right. You'll need the following tools for the job:

  • An adjustable wrench to loosen and tighten the mounting nut
  • Pliers, such as needle-nose or water pump pliers, to grip and manipulate the handle and chain
  • A towel to protect the toilet surface from scratches or damage during the process

Having these tools will help you have a smooth DIY experience. The right tools can really make a difference when fixing a broken toilet handle.

After you've got your tools ready, you can move on to removing the tank lid. Getting ready properly is important for a successful DIY plumbing project.

Remove the Toilet Tank Lid

The first step in replacing a toilet handle is to remove the toilet tank lid. Lift the lid from the toilet tank and carefully set it aside on a soft surface like a towel. This prevents scratching or damaging the surface.

Accessing the toilet tank is key to preparing for toilet handle replacement. By removing the toilet tank lid, you can see the inner workings of the toilet and the handle mechanism. This makes it easier for the next steps in the handle replacement process.

  1. Locate the toilet tank lid and gently lift it off the tank.
  2. Access the toilet tank by removing the lid, which will allow you to see the handle mechanism and other components.
  3. Place the lid on a soft, clean surface to prevent it from getting scratched or damaged while you work on the toilet.

With the tank lid removed, you can see the existing toilet handle and the parts you'll need for the replacement. This step prepares you for the next steps of detaching the lift chain and loosening the mounting nut to remove the old handle.

Detach the Lift Chain

The toilet handle is linked to a lift arm inside the tank. This arm connects to the flush valve or toilet flapper by a chain. To start replacing the handle, you must first detach this lift chain. It's important to find and unhook the chain correctly.

Locating the Lift Arm

Look inside the tank to find the lift arm where the chain is attached. It's usually at the top, connected to the outside handle. Note how the chain is attached to the arm for later reattachment.

Unhooking the Chain

Carefully take the chain off the lift arm. Remember which hole the chain's clasp is in for reattachment. Remove the chain without tangling or losing it.

Detaching the lift chain lets you take out the old handle and get ready for the new one. This step is key in the process of detaching toilet lift chain and removing toilet handle lift chain. It helps you access the toilet flush mechanism.

Loosen the Mounting Nut

To remove the old toilet handle, start by loosening the mounting nut. This nut is usually left-handed or reverse-threaded. So, you'll need to turn it clockwise to loosen it. If it's stuck, an adjustable wrench might help.

Getting ready to replace the toilet handle means loosening this nut first. This step is key to removing the old handle and preparing for the new one. Be careful and go slow to avoid damaging the porcelain tank.

  1. Find the mounting nut that holds the toilet handle.
  2. Use an adjustable wrench to turn the nut clockwise, loosening it bit by bit.
  3. If the nut is stuck, apply WD-40 or similar lubricant and wait a few minutes before trying again.
  4. Keep turning the nut until it's fully loose and the handle comes off.

Removing the toilet handle is a key step in replacing a broken or old one. By loosening the mounting nut, you can take off the old handle and prepare for the new one. This step is crucial for a successful toilet handle replacement.

Remove the Old toilet handle

With the mounting nut removed, you can now slip the lift arm through the tank hole. This action makes it easier to install the new handle.

Removing the old toilet handle is usually simple, but watch out for a few common issues. Many handles have left-hand threads. So, you must turn them counterclockwise to remove them. If the handle is corroded or stuck, this can be a challenge.

Sometimes, you'll need tools like a hacksaw blade, drill, or channellock pliers to free the handle. But be careful not to crack the tank. If the handle doesn't come off easily, you might need to find a new tank on eBay.

After removing the old handle, check the lift arm for holes where the chain connects. This information will help you attach the new handle correctly.

Replacing a toilet handle is a simple and affordable DIY task, with parts often under $20. But for fancy or unique toilets, the new handle could cost between $50 to $100.

toilet handle Replacement

Replacing a broken or worn-out toilet handle is easy and can make your bathroom look new. You can either install a new toilet handle or replace the old one. Just follow a few steps for a correct toilet handle installation.

Prepare the New Handle

First, prepare the new toilet handle. Remove the mounting nut and any O-rings or washers from the handle. This makes it easier to put the new handle into the tank.

Insert the New Arm

Next, guide the new handle's arm through the tank's hole from the outside. Some handles fit all toilets, while others fit certain positions like front, side, or angle-mounted. Make sure the new handle fits your toilet.

The nut that holds the handle is usually left-handed or reverse-threaded. You need to turn it clockwise to loosen it. Also, the arm's length and hole position might need adjusting during installation.

Don't over-tighten the mounting nut to avoid cracking the porcelain. A tight but not too tight fit is enough to keep the handle secure.

Secure the New Handle

Now that you've taken off the old toilet handle and got the new one ready, it's time to put it in place. You need to attach the mounting nut and make sure you don't tighten it too much. Tightening it too much could crack the porcelain.

Fasten the Mounting Nut

Put the rubber washer on the arm of the new toilet handle, then add the mounting nut. Use your hand to turn the nut counterclockwise to start tightening. Then, use a wrench to make it snug. The nut is often reverse-threaded, so you turn it the opposite way to secure it.

Avoid Over-Tightening

Don't tighten the mounting nut too much. This can damage the porcelain and cause cracks in the toilet tank. The instructions usually say to avoid using too much force. Just make sure it fits snugly to fasten the toilet handle mounting nut right.

It's easy to make the mistake of over-tightening the new toilet handle. But, it's crucial to avoid over-tightening to prevent porcelain damage. By following the steps carefully, you can secure the new toilet handle well. This ensures a smooth and reliable flush every time.

Reattach the Lift Chain

After removing the old toilet handle, it's time to reattach the lift chain. This chain is key for the toilet's flush mechanism. It links the handle to the flapper, letting you lift the flapper for flushing.

Adjust Chain Length

When putting the lift chain back, you might need to adjust its length. The right length depends on your toilet model. Different toilets have different lift arm lengths and hole positions.

If the chain is too long, the tank won't drain fully during flushes. If it's too short, the flapper might not close right, causing constant water flow. Finding the perfect length is crucial for good performance.

  1. Attach the lift chain to the same hole on the lift arm as the old one.
  2. Change the chain length by adding or removing links. Make sure the flapper moves smoothly.
  3. There should be about 1/2 inch of slack in the chain for the flapper's movement.
  4. If there are extra links, cut them off to avoid tank tangling.

Adjusting the chain length right is key for a reattaching toilet lift chain and a working toilet flush mechanism. This step prevents weak flushes or constant water flow.

Test and Fine-Tune

After reattaching the lift chain, it's time to test the new toilet handle and make any necessary adjustments. Start by doing a flush test to see if the handle works right and the tank drains fully.

Flush Test

Flush the toilet a few times to check how the handle performs. Watch the water level in the tank as it drains and fills back up. The tank should empty fully each time, and the flapper should close well when it fills.

If the flush doesn't work right, you might need to tweak the chain length or the handle's position. Adjustments can make a big difference.

Final Adjustments

If the flush still isn't good, try adjusting the chain length. A chain that's too long can stop the flapper from closing right, causing a weak flush. On the other hand, a chain that's too short might not let the flapper open enough, also causing weak flushing.

Keep adjusting the chain until you find the perfect length for a strong flush.

Also, check how the new toilet handle is positioned. Make sure it's even with the top of the tank and moves easily. Adjust it if needed for smooth operation and a dependable flush.

The aim is to have a toilet that flushes well and reliably. Take your time to test the new handle and make any final tweaks. This ensures your toilet works its best.

Maintenance Tips

Keeping your toilet handle in good shape is key to making it last longer and avoiding problems. Regular checks and simple steps can help your toilet handle work well for many years.

First, check the toilet handle often to make sure it's securely attached. Tighten the nut if needed to keep it from coming loose. Also, look at the lift chain or linkage that connects the handle to the flush mechanism. It should be adjusted right and not worn or damaged.

  • Regularly check the toilet handle for secure fastening
  • Inspect the lift chain or linkage for proper adjustment and condition
  • Address any issues with the handle or chain promptly to prevent further problems

If the toilet handle is worn or damaged, replace it right away. This fixes the toilet's function and saves you from expensive repairs later. Fixing toilet handle problems early helps your toilet last longer and keeps you from dealing with a broken toilet handle.

It's also a good idea to have a professional check your toilet once a year. A licensed plumber can look over the whole system, find any issues, and give advice on keeping your toilet working well. This can stop you from facing sudden toilet handle or plumbing problems.

  1. Replace the toilet handle if it becomes worn or damaged
  2. Schedule annual professional maintenance checks for your toilet
  3. Proactively address any toilet handle issues to prevent future problems

By following these tips, you can make sure your toilet handle keeps working right and your toilet lasts longer. Remember, a well-kept toilet handle is essential for a smooth plumbing system.

Conclusion

Replacing a broken toilet handle is easy and can make your bathroom look new again. Just follow the steps and tips given, and you'll fix your toilet handle in no time. Always use the right tools and be careful with the porcelain to ensure a smooth installation.

This guide has given you the skills to fix common toilet problems like a loose handle or a broken chain. You can save money and time by doing these repairs yourself. Just remember to understand the parts and follow the right steps.

If you're stuck or unsure, don't worry. Call 1-Tom-Plumber for help. They have certified technicians ready to assist you 24/7, even on holidays. They can fix your toilet right and prevent water damage or other issues.

HVAC Technician installing a electric heat pump
About Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc.
Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc. is a locally owned heating and air conditioning company that provides sales, service, and installation of any type of heating or cooling in your home or light commercial building.

Although the name Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc. is new, Mr. Richard Gilmer has been in the business of keeping his neighbors comfortable since 1998. As our presence in the HVAC contractors industry has evolved, we decided to change the name of our business to better reflect our commitment to the Middle TN area.

Our core values include implementing economically friendly products and practices to better contribute to the health and home of our customers. We are EPA certified and ensure that all refrigerant is recycled and all equipment is disposed of as per environmentally-safe standards. Our service techs and installers are trained to conduct business with minimal disruption to your daily lifestyle so that the only impact we make is a positive one

FAQ

Where should I check the location of my toilet handle before purchasing a replacement?

Check the toilet tank's handle location before buying a new one. Some handles fit universally, but others are made for specific spots like front-, side-, or angle-mounting.

How do I identify the type of toilet handle I currently have?

Figure out what kind of toilet handle you have - front-mounted, side-mounted, or angle-mounted. This helps pick the right replacement.

What tools do I need to replace a toilet handle?

You'll need an adjustable wrench, pliers, and a towel for protection when replacing a toilet handle.

How do I remove the old toilet handle?

Remove the old handle by loosening its left-handed or reverse-threaded nut. Use an adjustable wrench if needed.

How do I install the new toilet handle?

Put the new handle in by inserting the arm from outside the tank. Add the rubber washer and nut, then tighten the nut the opposite way.

How do I reattach the flush chain to the new toilet handle?

Put the flapper chain on the lift arm in the same spot as before. Adjust the chain length to make sure the tank drains well and the flapper seals right.

How do I test and fine-tune the new toilet handle?

Test the handle by flushing to see if it works right. If not, tweak the chain length or handle position as needed.

How can I maintain my toilet handle to prevent future issues?

Keep an eye on your toilet handle and make sure it's tight. Adjust the chain and check for wear or damage early. Fix any issues quickly to keep your handle working well.

HVAC Technician installing a electric heat pump
About Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc.
Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc. is a locally owned heating and air conditioning company that provides sales, service, and installation of any type of heating or cooling in your home or light commercial building.

Although the name Crossville Heating and Cooling, Inc. is new, Mr. Richard Gilmer has been in the business of keeping his neighbors comfortable since 1998. As our presence in the HVAC contractors industry has evolved, we decided to change the name of our business to better reflect our commitment to the Middle TN area.

Our core values include implementing economically friendly products and practices to better contribute to the health and home of our customers. We are EPA certified and ensure that all refrigerant is recycled and all equipment is disposed of as per environmentally-safe standards. Our service techs and installers are trained to conduct business with minimal disruption to your daily lifestyle so that the only impact we make is a positive one

Related Blog Posts

10 Signs its time for Proffesional Drain Cleaning Services
10 Signs its time for Proffesional Drain Cleaning Services
The 10 telltale signs that indicate it's time to call professional drain cleaning services. Keep your plumbing system running smoothly and avoid costly repairs.
Read More →
What Is a Sump Pump and how do they function?
What Is a Sump Pump and how do they function?
Discover what a sump pump is, how it protects your home from water damage, and why it's crucial for basement waterproofing. Learn about types and maintenance.
Read More →
Tankless Water Heater or Tank Water Heater? What's Better
Tankless Water Heater or Tank Water Heater? What's Better
Discover the pros and cons of tankless and tank water heaters to make the best choice for your home. Compare efficiency, cost, and performance of water heater options.
Read More →
Is Your Toilet Leaking from Tank to Bowl? Causes and Quick Fixes
Is Your Toilet Leaking from Tank to Bowl? Causes and Quick Fixes
Discover why your toilet is leaking from tank to bowl and learn quick fixes to stop the problem. Save water and money with our expert tips.
Read More →
Plumbing Inspection Services: What to expect
Plumbing Inspection Services: What to expect
Discover what to expect during a plumbing inspection. Learn about the process, common issues, and how to prepare your home for a thorough plumbing evaluation.
Read More →
No Hot Water in House? Quick Solutions Here
No Hot Water in House? Quick Solutions Here
Discover quick solutions for no hot water in house. Learn common causes and easy fixes to restore your hot water supply fast. Get expert tips and troubleshooting advice here.
Read More →
Fix Your Broken Toilet Handle: Easy DIY Solutions
Fix Your Broken Toilet Handle: Easy DIY Solutions
Learn how to fix a broken toilet handle with easy DIY solutions. Discover step-by-step instructions and tips to replace or repair your toilet handle quickly and efficiently.
Read More →
Is Your Water Heater making noise? Causes and Solutions
Is Your Water Heater making noise? Causes and Solutions
Discover why your water heater is making noise and learn effective solutions. From sediment buildup to pressure issues, we'll help you quiet your noisy water heater.
Read More →
How to Unclog a Toilet: Quick and Easy Solutions
How to Unclog a Toilet: Quick and Easy Solutions
Learn quick and effective methods for how to unclog a toilet without calling a plumber. Discover easy solutions using common household items and tools to fix your clogged toilet fast.
Read More →
HVAC Technician worker outside working on a ac unit

Need HVAC Service? 
Contact Us Today!

Stay comfortable year-round! Don't wait for a breakdown. Click here to schedule your HVAC repair or installation today!